Tattoo Liner - Vandfast eyeliner

was not dark, came out looking grey and i needed to use a different eyeliner to complete the look. returned immediately

I got the mini a while back as a sample, I’ve been using it and I’m LOVINGGG it! It stays on all day and is precise. I recommend this product!

GOAT eyeliner. I love it. Been using it for seven years

Unfortunately I'd pass

I used to LOVE this eyeliner but I think they refomulated and now my NYX eyeliner is 10x better unfortunately. This smudges BAD and is not cry/watery eye friendly like it used to be 😭

One of my favorites

I wanna give this product five stars so badly but unfortunately, it dries out quickly for my liking. But I love how dark black the liner is and how fine the tip is on the pen. I feel like I get the best winged liner with this product. Just wish it lasted longer and wasn’t so mad. 

Disappointed at first, but now like it

Been using this for so so many years (10 yrs at least) I really wasn’t sure how to feel about the newer formula - I was nearly heartbroken, but after using the entire liner I did ended up liking it. The brush is the best part and hope they never change that.

Rinse with hot water

Still my holy Grail. I read a few reviews about people complaining that they dry out too quickly now and I also thought the same…until I decided to one day run it under hot water and clean out all the dry eyeliner on the tip And it’s been four weeks later and it’s still working great. So I think sometimes the liquid gets dried on the fresh tip and we think that it’s out, but there is a hack to it ladies. The only sad part is it’s never in stock.

New formula sucks

Same as everyone else, I've been using this liner since it came out and it was the goat, but it seems the formula has changed and now sadly it smears all over your eyelid as the day goes on. It used to not budge, bring back the old formula!! why mess with a good thing?? so disappointing.

Used to be my favorite

I don’t know what happened to this product, but it’s not the same. I’ve used this for years upon years and it’s been my go-to. My cosmetics bag staple. At first I thought something was wrong with me or that I bought the wrong formulation. I started to scroll through recent reviews and found many people are experiencing the same problem. It’s not waterproof. It’s no longer long-lasting. Not only that, but it leaves a horrible black visible smudge on my eyelid. Please go back to the original formula! - Signed, Newly Stuck Without A Go-To Eyeliner

After using this product for over a year now I like how it last long since it waterproof, but it dries out too quickly

Its ruined

Why did they have to change the formula? I have been using this eyeliner for the past decade and it was the perfect eyeliner!! But now i have to find a new one because they changed the formula, now it stays sticky and comes off, super uncomfortable for my hooded eyelids, please bring the old formula back!

Best skinny liner

This is my favorite liner ever. The application is buttery smooth and I like the thin tip. I hope they never discontinue this.