Aqua XL - Ink Liner

This is perfection

My quest to find the perfect waterproof eyeliner is finish. This is the BEST of all worlds! I want to buy those for the rest of my life 10stars/5

Buying this for life

Will buy this for the rest of my life. Lasts all day, doesn't flake or smudge, completely waterproof! Please never discontinue this!!

My all time favourite liner!!

This is my go to eyeliner. I was so upset when it was unavailable for a couple of years because no matter what other brands I tried, I couldn’t find one that worked as well as this. The black is very (pigmented?), definitely stands out. Also, it’s the only brand that I’ve ever found that’s truly waterproof. Most other eyeliners I’ve tried that claim to be waterproof are far from that. I used to work as a lifeguard and would wear this and it would last even with me literally being submerged in water. The one downside you may find is, with any liquid pot liner, it does tend to get into the lashes if you don’t watch how much product is getting on the applicator and I can see why some ppl would get frustrated w that. To keep this from causing too much trouble w mascara for me, if you apply mascara right after applying for a single eye, you can kind of soften that problem.

terrible

Hate it. Application is uneven. By the end of the day it flakes off. The wand gets super sticky with product and gets stuck in my lashes when in apply it, it dries so quickly that I’m then stuck with chunks of it on my lashes. Disaster.

Definitely not matte and is super flaky when applying

I love this product!

First, I got this Eye Liner in Black (M-10) so I don't know what happened when I clicked in my order history this brown color came up. That aside, I love this liquid eye liner so much. It is very highly pigmented, and easier to apply for those of us who are mechanically impaired (uncoordinated). It lasted over 36 on one "bender" and I was really surprised. I just love the way it is applies, and how with once swipe there is such an intensity of color, and it lasts forever! I think it is my new favorite liquid eye liner.

my go-to

My go-to. Easy to apply and stays in place all day. Stings a bit if you get it in your eye.

I have been re-shocking this eyeliner for many years. I have oily eyes and this liquid eyeliner is really waterproof which helped me to prevent panda eyes. One thing I don't like is the new brush head. The old version is more firm which is easier for me to apply the liquid on specific spot, now the new version is too soft. I wish MAKE UP FOR EVER would consider to make some changes on the brush head.

No more melting eyeliner!

Perfect shade, easy to apply, lasts like it's supposed too! I've tried a ton of liquid liners at every price range. This is hands down the best.

Toss Your Other Liners, This is All You need

I've used this eyeliner for over 8 years now. I used a different liquid eyeliner from make up for ever before this that was discontinued (I unfortunately do not remember the name) and this was the exact same as that formula. It is the most opaque, easiest to apply liquid eyeliner ever. I hate the marker style liquid eyeliners because they drag and pull on the eye lid and it is difficult to get a sharp wing. With this, It never pulls. You cannot see any glittery or shimmer eyeshadow from under it. This is the only way I can get a perfect sharp wing. I always get complements on my eyeliner when I choose to wear it. It comes off easily with makeup wipes or remover, or will sometimes almost "chip" away on the wing if I'm crying lol. But I see that as a good thing since you want your makeup to be able to come off. But it does not smudge or budge in the heat or if touched by anything and you're not trying to purposefully remove it. I have very dry eyes and wear contacts. I've never had any irritation from my eyes with this, if that is a concern of yours. If you are not used to this style of liquid eyeliner (used to the marker style or gel with an angled brush), there may be a learning curve in how to hold the applicator since the base is farther way from the brush. But it only takes a few tried to get it down. Only product in my makeup routine that is my tried and true, holy grail, will never change. If you are on the fence, it is one thousand percent worth the money.

cheap quality don’t recommend

Terrible!!! Shame on MakeupForever for providing such cheap, cracking, dull, poorly made liner. What a waste of money. Had high hopes as saw images that looked nice of this product. It’s not even electric blue... it feels sticky, not even pharmacy has quality like this. Should’ve gotten the one in a jar instead of this, i got it because I usually respect quality of makeupforever as it’s supposed to be “professional” level. It’s so chappy and texture looks like cracking ice, rather have no liner than put this crap. Smh disappointed. :(((

Not quite as great as I had hoped...

This liner goes on pretty evenly and stays put, but this particular color was a lot darker than I expected it to be - it just looks black. Also when you remove it, it gets really flaky and it’s hard to get all the flakes off of your eyes and face. I have an older version of this in a turquoise color and I like that one a lot better.