Tattoo Liner - Vandfast eyeliner

Heartbreaking change in formula....

I have been using this eyeliner for many years. I am not sure what happened and if they changed the formula but I am very disappointed. I have hooded eyes and they eyeliner notoriously smudges and reprints on my eyelid my whole life. I have only ever been able to use liquid eyeliner with success. I really liked this option because it was both waterproof and it has a brush end not a sponge. This was out of stock last time i ordered and I tried another brand with horrible results. I finally ordered again and it reprinted and smudged off my eyes almost immediately. I could wipe it off with my finger.... I am heartbroken.

Buy It

This is the best eyeliner I have ever purchased. It glides on smoothly, is very easy to apply, and lasts all day without smudging or fading. Highly recommend.

Mediocre. Declined quality in new formula

I have been a cheerleader of the original creator and this brand since the early 2010s-from the scene kid days to the corporate office sphere. I’m a girl with big eyes with hooded eyelids and I am stating this new formula does not last more than 2 hours at best. It is drying. This used to be my go to eyeliner for an eight hour day. And I say with the original formula, I would be at class then work at the bars in college till 4 AM and this eyeliner used to stay on me. But this new formula is horrible. With how dry it is it now messes up my contact lenses when it flakes and smudges!! if you like it for it’s tip, there’s cheaper Korean waterproof eyeliners that are more available to the American market with even finer tips. This is no longer an award-winning formula…

Absolute must have!

Absolute must have! I've yet to find something comparable. Love love love this liner!

Perfect pen, but lasts maybe 4-6 hrs

My staple eyeliner. Draws the perfect wing ! However, it does not stay all day. Will need touch ups.

Not worth the $$$

It applies ok, and it is very waterproof! Does not wear super well. After a few hours it rubs off onto my upper lids. For the money you're better off buying the NYX Epic Ink Liner. Also very hard to apply over eye shadow / other make up.

So good!!

[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] This eyeliner is so nice and does not smudge!! It’s so pigmented and you can get a super smooth line with it. It also washes off pretty easily for me!!

was not dark, came out looking grey and i needed to use a different eyeliner to complete the look. returned immediately

I got the mini a while back as a sample, I’ve been using it and I’m LOVINGGG it! It stays on all day and is precise. I recommend this product!

GOAT eyeliner. I love it. Been using it for seven years

Unfortunately I'd pass

I used to LOVE this eyeliner but I think they refomulated and now my NYX eyeliner is 10x better unfortunately. This smudges BAD and is not cry/watery eye friendly like it used to be 😭

One of my favorites

I wanna give this product five stars so badly but unfortunately, it dries out quickly for my liking. But I love how dark black the liner is and how fine the tip is on the pen. I feel like I get the best winged liner with this product. Just wish it lasted longer and wasn’t so mad.