Exagger-Eyes Smokey Eye Kit - Makeup gaveæske

Good quality almost perfect.

I love this mascara. The bottle is made of glass and when you put the lid back on it clicks shut to make it air tight so it doesn’t dry up so fast. I like the mascara itself because it doesn’t dry make. My lashes longer but some times it makes them heavy and clumpy and doesn’t separate the lashes very well they just stick together. The eye pencil is nice it’s black (I thought it might have been brown as that’s the colour of the pencil) it’s very soft to put on but it is small and can be fiddly to use because its size. It also needs sharpening quite often because it’s so soft and goes on with ease but that also means it needs sharpening more often.

Makes your eyes pop

Daughter is in love with this, she loves the texture, packaging and colour is so intense, her favourite mascara and a very good price

Great gift

I love this mascara! The hold lasts pretty much all day, i love the size of the bottle too. My only issue was the type of brush, it wasnt the best for my lashes so I've been using a different brush for application.

The key to a great Smoky eye!

I’m really impressed with the Charlotte Tilbury Exaggereyes Smokey Eye Kit! The eyeliner is incredibly pigmented and rich, it glides on effortlessly without dragging. It also stays put all day without smudging, even on the waterline, it’s definitely the most durable eyeliner i have tried! The mascara adds great volume and length without clumping, making lashes look full and defined. The packaging looks and feels so luxe, making it a perfect gift for anyone who loves creating a bold, smokey eye look

Gorgeous gift set

This is a beautiful set and would make a really lovely gift for someone. It looks high end and the mascara in particular is great. I found it really easy to apply and it lasted well.

Great blending and easy to use

Great blending and pigmentation! Natural ingredients with neutral but pleasant scent, safe for sensitive and irritable skin. Fun packaging

Lovely clump free mascara

Lovely packaging. Really makes the product stand out. I was really pleased with the mascara in particular. It gave my lashes a natural light and was clump free. The eyeliner was too soft for my liking. Went on too easily and was very difficult to achieve the sleek look I like under the eyes. The makeup was scent free.

Overall a good buy!

Really like this set! I would be very happy to receive this as a present this christmas. Whilst im not prone to buying a brown liner, I find it perfect for my water line. The mascara is well made and dark. Stands out incredibly well on my lashes and gives me the volume I need without the need for false lashes.

Loooove!!

Love love looove this mascara!! Honestly one of the best I’ve ever tried. The eyeliner is so thick and creamy it goes on so easily which makes the product so long lasting too. Absolutely amazingly value for money!

Perfect gift this Christmas!

I have always loved Charlotte Tilbury make up and this duo would make the perfect gift this Christmas… I’d even gift it to myself! It comes with a mascara and eyeliner and both last all day! The mascara isn’t thick or clumpy and applies so easily. I love the eyeliner which blends well to create a Smokey eye look. Definitely recommend!

No clumping

Well I'm super impressed with this product. It really does what it states. The application rush for the mascara is perfect for getting a nice length on the lashes without any clumping. It divides the lashes equally with ease. When removing the wand from the tube you get the perfect amount of product so you don't really need to layer it. It drys nice and quickly with no transfer or smudging. I did find it took a little more effort to remove that my usual mascara but I'm not fussed about that . The eye liner is nice and soft and easy to apply. It has really good precision and is really easy to smudge in if you want a really defined smokey eye look . Again no smudging or transfer and was super easy to remove. The pencil stays sharp for quite a while so it should last for a good one time i normally use a retractable liner as i find you get less wastage with it . I love how bold and exciting the packaging is as it really stands out. It really is a great product that i need to do some experimenting with for different looks .

Love ❤️

My first impression of the Charlotte Tilbury EXAGGER-EYES Smokey Eye Kit was so good! The packaging immediately feels premium and festive — very on-brand for Charlotte Tilbury and perfect for Holiday 2025. The gold accents and compact design make it feel luxe and gift-worthy. I’d definitely be excited to receive this as a gift! The mini sizes are cute but practical, and the presentation feels elegant and high-quality. The mascara delivers beautiful volume and lift without clumping or flaking, and the eyeliner pencil is super smooth, glides on easily, and blends like a dream. Both are intensely black and well-pigmented, giving that bold, smoky look. I’ll mostly save this duo for special occasions since it gives such a striking finish — perfect for holiday parties or a night out! I’d absolutely consider gifting this set to friends or family. It’s a thoughtful and universally flattering choice for makeup lovers, whether they’re beginners or more experienced. The quality and presentation make it feel like a true luxury gift, and it definitely feels like good value for what you get. This is a set I’d be proud to give — or receive — this holiday season!