Aqua Smoky Extravagant

Can't compare to the original

The original was the best mascara I've ever used, hand down. This one leaves dark circles under my eyes after an hour of wear. Bring back the OG!!

Nope!

Not waterproof, bleeds on to eyelids after a few hours of wear. Doesn’t add much volume, brush shape is ridiculous. Now sad I bought it.

Grab this!

Excellent mascara and I’ve used a ton! I would highly recommend this mascara and I plan on ordering it again!

Lightweight formula, Amazing Wand!

I’ve been using this since 2013! I preferred the Original! I don’t find this one to be waterproof, just harder to remove! I do wish they would Bring the Original back! It’s the Only Mascara I’ve found to gives full and long Lashes!

Not for me - no volume, stubby lashes

This product does not build or add any volume. I returned it and went to another retailer to pick up Dior show.

Will always have in my drawer!

Love this mascara enough coverage and no smudging throughout day. Lasts 8 hrs!

No waterproof

I bought this mascara on a recommendation in the store, I had a test and the finish was very nice but when I used it to go out, the mascara was diluted in less than an hour, I am very disappointed because the price is very high.

I ended up looking like a raccoon 🦝

I love makeup forever but I ended up looking like a raccoon, the brush is also bulky and not practical. I wanted to love it but I was disappointed.

Don’t bother

I’m a fan of MF products in general so I thought I’d try the water proof mascara despite a low ratings. Not impressed. Without fail, after a couple of hours I have mascara all over my lower eyelid. I’ve tried setting it with tissue after application to remove any extra but doesn’t seem to make a difference. It has a gummy texture that I assume is meant to keep it in place but it just smears anyway and then is difficult to get off my skin. With the non-waterproof version of this mascara, when that happens it’s at least easy to wipe it away. I’m throwing this one in the trash and am on the hunt for a new mascara.

These were too smudgy and dont dry. Theyre thickening like all tge makeupforever mascaras but not good

Don't buy it

Don't buy it. They were out of the urban decay mascara normally get, so I bought this instead. It's worthless. Smudges like crazy and difficult to wash off completely. I hate it with a passion!

NOT WATERPROOF, SMUDGES LIKE CRAZY!

Gave me raccoon eyes in just 1 hour! Not Waterproof, definitely not even smudge-proof! Wand’s pointy end always glopped up in formula, photo is wrong: wide gaps in spirals ALL sides! Waste of money