Perfect Strokes - Matte Liquid Liner

Just awful

It was terrible. I wanted to like it so bad, but it ran way too quickly -- to the point that when I took the cap off, there were splatter marks in my sink. Eventually the applicator gets covered in the product and dries out, which clogs the mechanism that releases the product onto the applicator. It was super hard to get off my eyelashes -- because it runs so quickly it deposits too much product and ends up feeling, heavy.

Not very good

It was good for the first few days, then it quickly dried it out. I stored it upside down as Selena does in her ad and now the ink is all in the cap and running out of the tip.

Dried out within a month..

This liner is super quick to dry out not worth the money

I love the application, the consistency and wear of this product. Liquid eyeliner can be hot or miss but this became my go to product.

Best for bare skin

As someone who never leaves the house without a dark, crisp, winged liner look, let me break this down: First, I tested out the pigmentation on the back of my hand. It passed the test as a darker toned woman. It was streak free, very dark, and seemed to dry pretty quickly. It was semi-matte. Then, the real test began. I did my makeup as normal and primed my eyelids. This is important because I need to be sure any liner I use, especially one with a felt tip, can easily glide over eyeshadow and/or primer. This test, unfortunately wasn't a success. While I did take well to a first pass, thr felt tip seemed to absorb product making the remaining passes streaky and kind of transparent. It's a beautiful liner for my bare faced girlies, but for those of us that love a good eye look, may be best to go elsewhere.

Great precision with the applicator, lasts a while before drying out

A true matte and easy to use

Long lasting and just as good as KVD or Stilia brand!

My favorite liquid eyeliner

I have been using liquid liner since I was a teenager and this is the best I have found. I’m on my 4th one. It does last a long time and goes on matte black. Store it upside down for longer use.

Love love love!

The Rare Beauty black liquid liner has quickly become one of my absolute favorites. The formula is intensely pigmented, giving a true, deep black that doesn’t fade throughout the day. The brush tip is incredibly precise and flexible, making it easy to create anything from a thin, natural line to a bold wing—even if you’re not a makeup pro. What I love most is how smoothly it glides on without skipping, smudging, or transferring. It dries down to a clean matte finish that stays put all day, yet it’s still easy to remove at night. The liner feels lightweight, comfortable, and reliable—perfect for everyday wear or a glam look. Overall, it’s a must-have in any makeup bag. Rare Beauty really nailed this one!

Just right for me

My second time purchasing this eyeliner. Love how consistantly the product comes out, love the shape of the applicator since I can put it on thick or thin, and It never smudges but washes off easily. Lastly, my eyelids are now 45 years old, not young but not too old, and it goes on with no bleeding. Perfect!

Ok- Too long to apply

I tried the Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez eyeliner in Matte Black. Easy to apply, however, I had to do multiple passes to get the color I wanted. It is matte, does not have that shiny wet black most eyeliners do. Not NASA, just took too long for me.

Love love love

I’ve been using this for the past two years. Love it. Amazing. It’s very waterproof and somewhat crying proof LOL! But is it me or it dries up after 2-3 weeks? I know there’s product in there, I just gotta work an extra bit to get it to come out lol I kn