Maneater Mascara

Recommend

I like this mascara. I received a free sample with an order, and really liked it, so I ordered the full size. It adds really nice fullness and length.

Not my favorite, but very good

I ordered the brown just for something different (my go-to in mascara is always Blackest Black) and I was pleasantly surprised. Very natural looking, lashes still look black as it is a dark brown. I like how it goes on and I use a steamy hot rag to remove.

My honest opinion

I really wanted to try this one for awhile now so instead of getting my usual, I got this one to try instead, I was instantly disappointed. When It arrived, sadly it was already dried out, must of received old product. It was dry and did nothing for my lashes except clump. Lashes wouldnt separate. the more you try to fix it the worse it gets. A cheap drugstore brand would probably work better. Not worth the money and so disappointing.

My favourite mascara!! It gives a perfect combination of length and volume

PERFECT

Perfectly fans out every lash, thickening and elongating each and every one! It’s perfect for STUNNING, captivating, makes a prominent and noticeable impact! I use every day. The only mascara I’ll ever use! It honestly gets even better a couple months in!!!!

OBSESSED

Absolutely obsessed I get compliments on my eyes near daily. This is the only mascara I’ve used for at least 5 years. & the only mascara I will continue to use forever! I am so loyal to tarte bc of this product! ITS PERFECT!!! ❤️

Beautiful lashes, but not for me

Made my lashes look beautiful, long and separated. I immediately thought this was my new mascara, but a couple hours later I noticed quite a bit of flaking under my eyes. For what it's worth, I was wearing during the time of year that my eyes are bothered by allergies, and this may have contributed to the issue.

Amazing mascara

I got it as a sample, and now I keep buying it again and again. I really couldn't find any dupes for this mascara. It gives a very “clean” look, isn't clumsy, and stays all day.

Good!

I love this!!!! It's really good for the bottom eye lashes and for people with thicker eyelashes, I have longer straight lashes, so I prefer the tartelet mascara

Brown is AMAZING!

The brown mascara is a darker brown color but once applied is literally perfection. I have hazel eyes, brunette hair and this brown is so natural but bold. My new favorite!

Hands down the best mascara on the market

I have tried *probably* 98% of every mascara on the market, especially those for sensitive eyes. This is the only one that doesn’t irritate my eyes at all, and it’s not even advertised for that purpose! The coverage is phenomenal—it doesn’t clump out flake. It doesn’t run, so no raccoon eyes by the end of the day. Removing it is a breeze, and it removes completely. And the applicator brush?? The best!! I’ve paid twice what this mascara costs trying the others, and there just is nothing that compares to this.

Try it, you won’t regret it

I’ve tried a lot of mascaras but this one is my favorite !!!! I have it in the black and really gives my lashes volume ! 10/10 just purchased the brown to try out as well