Flypencil - Longwear Eyeliner

Gorgeous Shade with Quality Concerns

I absolutely love the color of this Fenty Beauty eyeliner—it’s truly unique, and I haven’t found a similar shade in any other brand. However, the main downside is that the eyeliner breaks very easily. Even with minimal pressure while applying, the tip tends to snap off, which can be really frustrating. I was hopeful that the quality would improve over time, but after two years, I faced the same issue again. It’s a bit of a letdown given how beautiful the color is.

This is definitely long wearing but it smears easily and if you line the bottom lashes it runs quickly. Good navy color

it's super dry, sand like texture, just used it once, and it was so hard on my skin that it literally hurt my right away

Bad batch? Expired??

This is awful. There is no way it is supposed to be so dried out. You can see in the pics, it is crumbling right off my hand. Is this a bad batch?? I’d love it in a useable formula because the color is perfect.

dried out

not sure if this was an old product but was so dry it didn't leave any colour on my eyes

Big disappointment

The twisting up takes forever and cannot be retracted. The application is the farthest from creamy. It’s chalky, flaky, and it required the hardest pressure to get meager payoff. I swatched it on the back of my hand, and I instantly knew it was a return. I would never use so much pressure anywhere near my eye. I had such high hopes for this product, and I was totally let down. Unfortunately, it has changed my view of the brand toward the negative.

poor quality

the color is bright and nice BUT the application is poor. The crayon kept breaking off while applying it to my eyelids

This liner was terrible, super dry and hard to draw with. I had to push very hard to get a chalky line.

Read reviews before buying

Unfortunately first time I bought, the product was dry. Returned and exchange only to find that when you apply the product firmly to your hand it’s vibrant and looks promising but when it comes to goth eye lid where it’s supposed to work. Product doesn’t come out smoothly unless you’re pressing hard. Not good when it’s a sensitive area on your face. Not sure if the formula should be made again. But I’m disappointed since I loved fenty’s other products. Really should have saved my money for drug store eyeliner and read reviews before purchasing.

Not recommended

Extremely disappointed with this eyeliner. The formula is so stiff that it drags on my eyelids when I try to apply it. Even after multiple swipes with heavy pressure, the color payoff is weak.

Not a good product at all

If I could I would give this zero stars. Do not buy! It was horrible! As soon as it touched your eyelid and you tried to use it, it broke every single time! It also wouldn’t glide,it was so hard and stiff. Not a good product .i love Fenty but not this!actually

Initially nice, then dried up and became unusable

I have a few Fenty products - all great... but this one was disappointing. Loved it at first, but it dried out very quickly and became unusable about 1/2 way through. (I bought another eye liner at the same time which is still going strong, so I think it's the formula that is off somehow.